Close Menu
New Delhi PostNew Delhi Post
    What's Hot

    FROM PHARMACY TO PARTY DRUGS: How Prescription Medicines Are Fueling India’s Youth Intoxication Crisis

    THE GREAT BANK FEE TRAP: How Banks Turn Everyday Charges into a Billion-Dollar Business

    Big Business, Dirty Mining: Five leading cement makers linked to mines accused of illegal extraction

    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    New Delhi PostNew Delhi Post
    Subscribe Sunday, November 22
    • HOME
    • EXCLUSIVE
    • STATECRAFT
      • CENTRE
      • EAST
      • WEST
      • NORTH
      • SOUTH
      • NORTHEAST
    • WORLDVIEW
    • PERSPECTIVE
    • CONVERSATION
    • LIFE & STYLE
      • BOOK
      • FOODIE
      • ART & CULTURE
      • GLAMOUR
      • HEALTH
      • RELATIONSHIP
      • TREND
      • TRAVEL
    • MISC.
      • BEYOND FILTERS
      • DIASPORA
      • EARTH
      • ECONOMY
      • EXPLAINED
      • FUTURE
      • NEWSMAKER
      • OFFBEAT
      • PLAYING TO THE GALLERY
      • SPORTS
      • SCIENCE & TECH
    • Magazine
    New Delhi PostNew Delhi Post
    Home»perspective

    Food Adulteration, Fake Medicines: Why Have India’s Regulators Failed Consumers?

    Rakesh K. ChitkaraBy Rakesh K. Chitkara
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email WhatsApp

    For years, India’s food and medical safety system operated in comfortable silence. Samples failed, files moved, licences were renewed, and nothing changed. The silence suited everyone except consumers.

    This year, Maharashtra’s Food and Drug Administration (FDA) commissioner, Tukaram Mundhe, broke that silence.

    In six months since May, the state FDA acted against 12,083 entities, issued 603 suspension orders and cancelled or suspended 740 pharmacy licences. In Jalgaon, officials found cow’s milk adulterated with edible oil to make synthetic milk. Inspectors checked five-star hotels, cricket club kitchens, quick-commerce warehouses, pizza chains and roadside stalls. During Diwali week, they suspended more than 100 food licences, including those of Blinkit and Zepto outlets.

    These adulteration practices did not begin when Mundhe took charge in May. He simply acted against them. Every regulator, minister and trade body that knew and stayed silent now owes the public an answer.

    Mundhe’s appointment was the 25th transfer in his 21-year career, a reflection of his reputation for honesty. This time, Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis stood firmly behind him. A day after the Bombay High Court penalised the FDA, Fadnavis publicly backed the crackdown and said it would continue. Every chief minister has officers capable of doing what Mundhe is doing. Few protect them.

    Last financial year, India tested 223,808 food samples. Of these, 40,023 failed, nearly one in five. There were only 1,918 criminal convictions, fewer than one for every 20 failures. Uttar Pradesh reported the highest number of failures among states.

    Officials also tested 1.41 lakh medicine samples. Of these, 3,012 were not of standard quality and 283 were spurious or adulterated. How many convictions followed? The public has not been told.

    Adulteration is a business with healthy margins across the value chain and little risk of punishment.

    The Union Health Ministry, under J P Nadda, says food safety is a shared responsibility because around 98 per cent of food businesses fall under the states. No one has asked Chief Ministers how many food safety officers their states have for every 1,000 establishments.

    The Drugs Controller General of India (DCGI), also under Nadda’s watch, knows the industry well. After the Chhindwara deaths, the DCGI wrote to states that manufacturers were not always testing every batch of raw materials and finished products, as required.

    Then there is Pharmexcil (Pharmaceuticals Export Promotion Council of India), under the Commerce Ministry headed by Piyush Goyal. Indian-made cough syrups have been linked to the deaths of more than 140 children in Africa and Central Asia since 2022. Pharmexcil suspended Maiden Pharmaceuticals’ membership and later Marion Biotech’s, cutting their access to export incentives. Withdrawing benefits after the funerals is not regulation.

    Goyal speaks of USD 1 trillion in exports this fiscal year and invokes the Prime Minister’s Zero Defect, Zero Effect call. The promise rings hollow when overseas patients consume unsafe Indian-made cough syrups or use substandard eye drops.

    OPPI (Organisation of Pharmaceutical Producers of India), which represents multinational drug companies, speaks forcefully about patent violations in India. Through PhRMA (Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America), it also ensures that US concerns are recorded annually in the Special 301 report. It is silent, however, on counterfeit versions of members’ brands being sold in Indian pharmacies.

    The Indian Pharmaceutical Alliance (IPA) advocates easing price controls and regulations. It is silent when members’ products are faked and spurious exports damage the “pharmacy of the world” reputation.

    These are not obscure brands. In July, a Dehradun factory was raided for allegedly faking medicines under the names of Cipla, Lupin, Dr Reddy’s, Abbott, Sun Pharma and Zydus. In Puducherry, officers seized counterfeit Torrent, Sun Pharma and Abbott products worth about ₹30 crore, along with machinery used to produce authentic-looking holograms and QR codes.

    Brand owners typically respond that the seized batches are not theirs. Such clarifications may protect companies, not patients who may already have been harmed. Samples are drawn from pharmacies, not necessarily from factory gates.

    Smaller associations, meanwhile, spent their energy seeking more time to comply with revised Schedule M requirements. The Federation of Pharma Entrepreneurs (FOPE), Laghu Udyog Bharati and state manufacturers’ associations sought to push the deadline to December 2026. By the end of 2025, only 1,400 of 6,500 micro, small and medium enterprise (MSME) drug firms had submitted upgrade plans. The extension was refused, and the rules have applied to every unit since January this year.

    How many trade bodies have suspended a member whose batch appeared in a regulator’s alert? The answer is obvious.

    Mundhe has demonstrated a principle the rest of India needs. When he served notices on Shah Rukh Khan, Ajay Devgn and Tiger Shroff over a Vimal Elaichi advertisement, he sought their endorsement agreements, payment arrangements and proof of due diligence. He later urged endorsers, in effect, to let their own children consume the product first.

    The principle is simple: whoever lends their name must answer for what it sells. A film star is accountable for an advertisement, a chief executive for a company’s factory, and an association president for its members. The solutions are neither new nor expensive. They require political will.

    Personal accountability: Food and drug companies above a specified size should file annual quality certificates signed by their chief executives. False declarations should attract personal liability.

    A national register: Link cancelled food and drug licences to the owner’s Permanent Account Number (PAN) or Aadhaar. A closed business should not be able to reopen under a relative’s name.

    Fast-track justice: Send adulteration and spurious drug cases to designated courts with fixed timelines. A conviction rate below 5 per cent cannot deter offenders.

    Public scorecards: The Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) and the Central Drugs Standard Control Organisation (CDSCO) should publish quarterly state-wise figures on samples tested, failures, convictions and inspector vacancies. Voters should be able to compare their Chief Ministers’ records.

    Accountable membership: Pharmexcil should link export membership to Schedule M compliance and a clean regulatory record before shipment, not after deaths. OPPI, IPA and other trade bodies should disclose members named in regulatory alerts and the action taken.

    Authentication: Companies whose brands are counterfeited should fund effective pack-level authentication and rewards for reporting fakes.

    Security of tenure: Food and drug commissioners need a fixed minimum tenure. Last month, rumours of Mundhe’s transfer spread after he received additional charge on an MPSC inquiry committee. He had to publicly confirm that he remained at the FDA. The next Mundhe should not need a chief minister’s personal protection to do the job.

    One commissioner has shown that the law works when enforced. Whether the silence stays broken depends on Nirman Bhawan, Vanijya Bhawan, state secretariats and association boardrooms.

    Uttar Pradesh, which reported the highest number of failed food samples, goes to the polls in 2027. Food and medicine safety has never decided an Indian election. Will any political party make it an election issue?

    Rakesh K. Chitkara
    Rakesh K. Chitkara

    Keep Reading

    A World Moving Towards Three Poles: What Will be India’s Role?

    27 Lakh Voters’ Eligibility Undecided: How Was the Bengal Polls Held? Was It Constitutionally Valid?

    BJP’s Vote Bank Isn’t Collapsing. Its Blank Cheque is

    Makkah Pact Tests India’s Strategy as West Asia Reshapes Its Security Order

    Judiciary Needs Introspection Before Public Trust Erodes Further

    From Ottoman Enemies to Mecca Allies: What Changed?

    Add A Comment
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Subscribe to News

    Get the latest sports news from NewsSite about world, sports and politics.

    Advertisement
    Demo
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube
    • About Us
    • Exclusive
    • statecraft
    • worldview
    • perspective
    • conversation
    • Life & Style
    • Misc.
    • Magazine
    • Get In Touch
    • About Us
    • Exclusive
    • statecraft
    • worldview
    • perspective
    • conversation
    • Life & Style
    • Misc.
    • Magazine
    • Get In Touch
    © 2026 New Delhi Post. Designed by Rynow Infotech . All rights reserved.
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms & Conditions

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.